There are ninety seconds from 2017 I have never described to another human being, including the three people who were in the room with me.
I work approach control at a facility I won't name. Forty-six, wife, two kids, a pension I can see from here.
First, so you read the rest correctly: the job isn't stressful the way movies show. Nobody shouts. It's six hours of being correct, in two-hour pushes, and the correctness is not optional and does not care how you slept. Most shifts are boring in a specific way — the kind of boring that requires total attention.
You're watching twelve airplanes and you're three moves ahead of all twelve, and if you drop a thread you don't notice immediately, which is the entire problem.
In 2017 I dropped a thread.
No call signs. Here's the shape. I had a heavy on a long final. I had a smaller aircraft out on a vector and I had an intention for him — a plan, in my head, for where he'd be in ninety seconds. I turned to coordinate with the sector next to me, which happens two hundred times a shift.
When I turned back, my plan and reality had come apart. Not slowly. They were already apart.
I fixed it. That's the thing I need to say. A turn and a descent, separation restored, nobody hurt, nobody filed anything, the pilots said nothing. By the numbers it wasn't even a reportable event. By the numbers it never happened.
But I know what I didn't do and how much room I had. I've done this long enough to know exactly what the other version looks like, because I've read every report of every other version since 1980. I know the phrase they use in the findings.
I've sat in recurrent training watching animations of other people's worst ninety seconds thinking, in a quiet part of my head, that was almost exactly me, I just got the turn out in time.
I never told my wife. Not because she wouldn't understand — she'd be kind, she'd say the thing you're about to say in the comments, which is that I fixed it and that's the job. I didn't tell her because I didn't want the sentence to exist out loud in my house.
I didn't tell my coworkers either, and that's harder to explain. Our culture is genuinely good about reporting and I believe in that system. But there's a difference between a system that protects you and a room full of people whose professional self-respect rests on being the one who doesn't need protecting.
I know how we talk about other people's close calls. We're sympathetic for about four minutes.
What it did: for two years I stopped turning my head. Literally. I'd coordinate without breaking my scan, which sounds like good practice and is actually a compulsion. My supervisor noticed I'd gotten slow on coordination. I said I was being careful. He let it go, because he's decent.
Then I went back to normal, which frightens me more than the event did. Because there's nothing to fix. I wasn't tired, I wasn't on my phone, I hadn't skipped my break. I was a competent person having an average Tuesday.
The lesson, if there is one, is that the margin is thinner than the public thinks and thinner than we tell each other, and it's held together by people turning their heads back at the right moment, several thousand times a day, forever.
Six years to retirement. I'll make it. I'm good at this and I'm not writing because I think I'm dangerous. I'm writing because I'll carry those ninety seconds out of this building when I go, and I wanted them written down by the person they belong to.
Comments